Pilot grew 58.0% to 2,092,981 visits while Kruze Consulting fell 42.1%, and Pilot now draws 68.7% of the category’s web visits.
We analysed twelve months of SEMrush Traffic Analytics data for five firms selling outsourced bookkeeping, accounting and fractional CFO services: visits, engagement, channel mix, monthly trends for every channel, and AI referrals by assistant. Every figure below is computed from the SEMrush exports and compared with the prior twelve months or across the two halves of the year.
- 5 competitors
- Period: Nov 2025 to Oct 2026
- Compared with Nov 2024 to Oct 2025
- Source: SEMrush
Change in visits, Nov 2025 to Oct 2026 against the prior twelve months
+58.0%
+22.0%
+13.8%
+10.8%
-42.1%
The category grew 25.9%. Strip out Pilot and the other four shrank 13.0%.
Visits in each twelve-month period, with change year on year
- Nov 2024 to Oct 2025
- Nov 2025 to Oct 2026
Pilot drew 2,092,981 visits in the twelve months to October 2026, up 58.0% from 1,324,687, and its unique visitors rose 53.1%. It added 768,294 visits, more than the category’s entire net gain of 625,816, because the rest of the set lost ground. Kruze Consulting fell 42.1%, from 565,187 to 327,406, and its unique visitors fell further (-43.0%). A year earlier Kruze Consulting drew 42.7% as many visits as Pilot; now it draws 15.6%.
Paro grew 22.0% to 377,573 and passed Kruze Consulting for second place, drawing more visits than Kruze Consulting in every month from December 2025. Bookkeeper360 grew 13.8% to 134,870 and Supporting Strategies 10.8% to 112,326. Together the four firms other than Pilot drew 952,175 visits, down from 1,094,653.
The months show where the gap opened. Pilot’s visits ran from 113,711 in November 2025 to a peak of 243,693 in January 2026, and January to March alone carried 33.8% of its year. Kruze Consulting’s best month was the first, November 2025, at 40,029; it reached its low in June 2026 at 19,245 and ended October at 23,551, 41.2% below where it started.
Scale note. Pilot is not a like-for-like peer. It drew 18.6 times the visits of Supporting Strategies and 2.2 times the other four combined, so category totals mostly describe Pilot. The comparisons below report the other four on their own wherever that changes the reading.
Five firms, sorted by growth year on year
| Competitor | Visits | Visits, prior year | YoY | Second half vs first | Share of set | Largest channel | Organic search visits | Paid search visits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pilotpilot.com | 2,092,981 | 1,324,687 | +58.0% | -11.1% | 68.7% | Direct (40.0%) | 512,810 | 430,666 (20.6%) |
| Paroparo.ai | 377,573 | 309,549 | +22.0% | +0.7% | 12.4% | Direct (41.5%) | 98,387 | 70,625 (18.7%) |
| Bookkeeper360bookkeeper360.com | 134,870 | 118,530 | +13.8% | -13.9% | 4.4% | Direct (46.7%) | 48,846 | 5,031 (3.7%) |
| Supporting Strategiessupportingstrategies.com | 112,326 | 101,387 | +10.8% | +17.9% | 3.7% | Direct (46.8%) | 40,392 | 2,012 (1.8%) |
| Kruze Consultingkruzeconsulting.com | 327,406 | 565,187 | -42.1% | -20.6% | 10.8% | Direct (44.0%) | 132,482 | 10,866 (3.3%) |
Source: SEMrush Traffic Analytics, Overview, monthly Visits and Traffic Journey. Visits cover Nov 2025 to Oct 2026; prior year is Nov 2024 to Oct 2025. Second half vs first compares May to Oct 2026 with Nov 2025 to Apr 2026. Channel shares are of each firm’s Traffic Journey total. Organic search visits are Traffic Analytics channel visits, not Domain Overview organic traffic. Authority Score is not part of this edition.
Four findings that hold across the category
All five run on direct and organic search. Only two of them buy search as well.
Direct is the largest channel at every firm, from 40.0% of visits at Pilot to 46.8% at Supporting Strategies, and organic search is second at all five. The split comes after that. Paid search brings Pilot 20.6% of its visits and Paro 18.7%. At Bookkeeper360 it is 3.7%, at Kruze Consulting 3.3% and at Supporting Strategies 1.8%.
The firms that do not buy search lean hardest on earning it. Organic search is 40.4% of Kruze Consulting’s visits, the highest share in the set, 36.1% of Bookkeeper360’s and 35.9% of Supporting Strategies’. Pilot also dominates paid social, with 90.0% of the set’s paid social visits.
Share of visits by channel, Nov 2025 to Oct 2026
- Direct
- Organic search
- Paid search
- All other channels
Organic search fell at four of the five between the halves. Kruze Consulting fell furthest, 35.1%.
Across the set, organic search visits from May to October 2026 were 26.4% below November to April, while direct visits rose 7.8%. Kruze Consulting lost 37,536 visits between the halves; organic search accounts for 28,244 of them, 75.2% of the drop. Kruze Consulting was also the only firm whose direct visits fell (-8.3%). Pilot’s organic search fell 29.3% and its paid search 29.9%, while its direct visits rose 9.9%. Bookkeeper360’s organic search fell 24.5% and Paro’s 11.9%.
Supporting Strategies, the smallest firm in the set, moved the other way. Its organic search rose 13.1% and its direct visits 31.1%, the strongest direct gain of the five, and its total visits were 17.9% higher in the second half than the first.
Source: SEMrush Traffic Analytics, monthly Direct, Organic Search and Paid Search channels. Modelled estimates.
Visits got shorter at all five firms. Pilot’s visits still last longest, at 07:40.
Pilot’s average visit fell from 11:06 to 07:40 (-30.9%) even as its visits grew, though its bounce rate improved from 60.61% to 55.46%. Bookkeeper360 saw the sharpest change: visits fell from 16:40 to 05:01 (-69.9%) and pages per visit from 5.8 to 2.3, a shift large enough that it may reflect how its site is structured or measured rather than visitor behaviour alone. Supporting Strategies fell 45.1% to 03:26, Kruze Consulting 25.3% to 04:44 and Paro 9.7% to 04:29.
Bounce rates split the set. Kruze Consulting’s is the highest, at 75.64%, and rose from 73.28%; Paro’s also rose, to 66.95%. Supporting Strategies’ improved 13.44 points to 45.04%, the lowest in the set, and its unique visitors grew 32.2%, faster than its visits.
Average visit duration (mm:ss) in each twelve-month period, with change year on year
- Nov 2024 to Oct 2025
- Nov 2025 to Oct 2026
Kruze Consulting draws the most AI assistant referrals per visit and posted the steepest organic search fall. The data shows both, not a link between them.
Per 10,000 visits, AI assistants send Kruze Consulting 228.8, Paro 122.0, Bookkeeper360 120.0, Supporting Strategies 107.7 and Pilot 88.9. Kruze Consulting’s rate is 2.6 times Pilot’s. Over the same year its organic search visits fell 35.1% between the halves, while across the five ChatGPT referrals moved +0.3%.
Correlation, not causation. This page reports AI referrals and organic search movements side by side and makes no claim that one caused the other, including Kruze Consulting’s organic decline. AI referrals are at most 2.3% of visits at any of the five, far too small to explain these swings alone, and this data cannot show cause. AI Overview keyword coverage is not part of this edition.
AI assistant referral visits per 10,000 visits, with change in organic search visits half on half
228.8
122.0
120.0
107.7
88.9
Six gaps. Two are open here.
Paid search is a two-firm market. Pilot and Paro draw 96.6% of the category’s paid search visits.
Paid search sent the five 519,200 visits in the year: Pilot 430,666 and Paro 70,625. Kruze Consulting, Bookkeeper360 and Supporting Strategies drew 17,909 between them. Pilot alone drew 40 times Kruze Consulting’s paid search visits.
For a business owner searching for an outsourced bookkeeper or a fractional CFO, the paid results are close to a two-firm contest. Pilot’s own paid search visits fell 29.9% in the second half, so the space may be loosening. Modelled paid figures track measurable investment, so read low numbers as little visible spend rather than proof of none.
No firm owns AI recommendations. ChatGPT and Claude favour Pilot, Perplexity and Google AI Mode favour Kruze Consulting, and Gemini favours Paro.
The five leading AI assistants sent the set 12,336 visits in the year, 53.3% of them from ChatGPT. Pilot drew 6,509, Kruze Consulting 3,192, Paro 1,599, Bookkeeper360 706 and Supporting Strategies 330. Pilot took 54.6% of ChatGPT referrals and 86.3% of Claude’s, and Claude supplies 36.7% of Pilot’s named AI referrals. Kruze Consulting, with 10.8% of category visits, took 50.4% of Perplexity referrals and 60.8% of Google AI Mode’s. Paro led on Gemini with 42.7%.
The volumes are small, which is the opening. Which firm gets recommended depends on which assistant the buyer asks, and a firm a fraction of Pilot’s size already wins two of the five.
What took Kruze Consulting’s organic search down 35.1% between the halves
In full report
Why SEMrush models Paro’s purchase conversion at 1.99%, up from 0.71%, against Pilot’s 0.12%
In full report
Whether Pilot’s 430,666 paid search visits are buying growth or defending it
In full report
How Supporting Strategies grew organic search 13.1% while the other four fell
In full report
Get the full outsourced accounting and fractional CFO report
- All six gaps, with the figures behind each and the move we would make
- Twelve months of monthly traffic by channel for every firm
- A month by month read of how Pilot pulled away and Paro passed Kruze Consulting
- AI referral sources for each firm, AI tool by AI tool
Tell us your vertical and we will send the full outsourced accounting and fractional CFO report.
We send the report by email and follow up once to offer a walkthrough.
Method and provenance
- Source
- SEMrush Traffic Analytics: Overview, Traffic Journey, monthly Visits, monthly channel trends (direct, organic search, referral, paid search, organic social, paid social, email, display, ChatGPT) and AI traffic by source exports for pilot.com, kruzeconsulting.com, bookkeeper360.com, paro.ai and supportingstrategies.com.
- Market
- Worldwide, all devices. Figures are not limited to any one country.
- Competitor set
- Five firms selling outsourced bookkeeping, accounting and fractional CFO services online. They are not of equal scale: Pilot drew 68.7% of the set’s visits, 5.5 times the next largest firm, Paro, and 18.6 times the smallest, Supporting Strategies. Results for the other four are reported separately where Pilot would otherwise dominate a total.
- Modelled data
- Visit, engagement, conversion and channel figures are SEMrush modelled estimates, not first-party analytics from any of these companies. They are suitable for comparing competitors with each other and over time, not for stating any company’s exact traffic. Visits include every subdomain, so clients signed in to portals hosted on these domains count alongside visitors to marketing pages. Purchase conversion is SEMrush’s own modelled metric; SEMrush reports none for Supporting Strategies in this period.
- AI exposure
- AI referral visits and organic search movements are reported as correlation only. Nothing on this page claims that AI assistants or AI Overviews caused a change in organic or any other traffic. AI Overview keyword coverage is not part of this edition. AI referral rates use the Traffic Journey AI traffic channel. Named referrals cover the five leading AI tools (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Mode): 12,336 visits, 36.8% of the AI traffic channel; SEMrush attributes the rest to smaller tools or names no source.
- Period
- Nov 2025 to Oct 2026, compared with Nov 2024 to Oct 2025. Half-year comparisons set the first half of the period (Nov 2025 to Apr 2026) against the second (May to Oct 2026) and are not seasonally adjusted, which matters in a category with a tax calendar. The monthly exports also carry a November 2026 row; it is an incomplete month and is excluded throughout.
- Rounding
- Visits are shown as whole numbers, except category totals, shown in millions to two decimal places. Percentages and growth rates are computed from the raw counts and shown to one decimal place (bounce rates and conversion to two, as SEMrush reports them), so shares may not sum to exactly 100%. Bounce rate changes are in percentage points. Channel shares are of each firm’s Traffic Journey total, which differs from Overview visits by at most 0.26%.
- Not in this edition
- Authority Score, organic keyword positions, branded and non-branded search, backlinks, referring domains, paid search creative, AI Overview coverage and top pages by share of traffic.