Rightway’s visits rose 172.1% from the first quarter of the year to the last, from 39.7% of MedImpact’s to 96.6%.
We analysed twelve months of SEMrush Traffic Analytics data for five transparent and pass-through pharmacy benefit managers: visits, engagement, channel mix, monthly trends for every channel, and AI referrals by assistant. Every figure below is computed from the SEMrush exports and compared with the prior twelve months or across the year.
- 5 competitors
- Period: Oct 2025 to Sep 2026
- Compared with Oct 2024 to Sep 2025
- Source: SEMrush
Change in visits, Jul to Sep 2026 against Oct to Dec 2025
+172.1%
+36.2%
+28.7%
+11.6%
+7.4%
Every PBM in the set grew through the year. Rightway grew 4.7 times as fast as the next, and in August 2026 it out-drew MedImpact.
Visits in the first and last quarter of the period, with full-year change year on year
- Oct to Dec 2025
- Jul to Sep 2026
Rightway drew 259,929 visits in October to December 2025 and 707,189 in July to September 2026, a rise of 172.1%. Navitus was next fastest at +36.2%, then Judi Health (+28.7%), MedImpact (+11.6%) and SmithRx (+7.4%). In August 2026 Rightway recorded 312,460 visits against MedImpact’s 310,218, the only month in the period in which MedImpact was not the largest site in the set.
Over the full year MedImpact still leads with 3,391,993 visits, 45.4% of the set and 2.1 times Rightway’s 1,654,193. But Rightway’s year-on-year rise of 146.2% took it from 36.9% of MedImpact’s traffic to 48.8%. Direct visits carried most of it: Rightway’s direct visits went from 112,968 to 358,577 between the two quarters, 54.9% of its total gain.
Quarters are compared rather than half years because two single-month spikes, MedImpact’s February 2026 (574,262 visits, 1.8 times its next-highest month) and Navitus’s January 2026 (192,641), fall between them. On half years MedImpact reads -5.5%, a result of that one month.
Five PBMs, sorted by momentum through the year
| Competitor | Last quarter vs first | Visits, full year | YoY | Share of set | Largest channel | Organic search visits | Paid search visits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rightwayrightwayhealthcare.com | +172.1% | 1,654,193 | +146.2% | 22.1% | Direct (47.2%) | 346,326 | 102,147 (6.2%) |
| Navitusnavitus.com | +36.2% | 1,167,111 | +43.5% | 15.6% | Direct (45.2%) | 366,758 | 9,154 (0.8%) |
| Judi Healthjudi.health | +28.7% | 534,549 | +7,891.5%* | 7.1% | Direct (42.3%) | 187,670 | 7,526 (1.4%) |
| MedImpactmedimpact.com | +11.6% | 3,391,993 | +86.3% | 45.4% | Direct (53.9%) | 819,094 | 23,382 (0.7%) |
| SmithRxsmithrx.com | +7.4% | 731,376 | +163.6% | 9.8% | Organic Search (48.7%) | 356,157 | 16,980 (2.3%) |
Source: SEMrush Traffic Analytics, Overview, monthly Visits and Traffic Journey. Last quarter vs first compares Jul to Sep 2026 with Oct to Dec 2025. Channel shares are of each PBM’s Traffic Journey total. Organic search visits are Traffic Analytics channel visits, not Domain Overview organic traffic. Authority Score is not part of this edition. *Not like for like: the judi.health domain had little traffic in the prior year.
Four findings that hold across the category
Four of the five run on direct traffic. SmithRx is the only one that depends on search.
Direct is the largest channel at MedImpact (53.9%), Rightway (47.2%), Navitus (45.2%) and Judi Health (42.3%), consistent with members, pharmacists and plan sponsors returning to sites they already use. Referral adds 16.9% at MedImpact and 17.5% at Navitus.
SmithRx takes 48.7% of its visits from organic search and 34.1% direct, the reverse of everyone else. It also has the highest paid search share outside Rightway, at 2.3%. Across the set, AI assistants account for 0.31% of visits and Google AI Mode for none.
Share of visits by channel, Oct 2025 to Sep 2026
- Direct
- Organic search
- Paid search
- All other channels
Rightway drew 64.2% of all paid search visits in the set, and the largest share of social and email too.
Rightway recorded 102,147 paid search visits, 6.2% of its traffic; no other PBM takes more than 2.3% of its visits from paid search. It also drew 44.7% of the set’s organic social visits and 41.5% of its email visits.
Those channels grew with it. Between the first and last quarters Rightway’s email visits rose 339.5%, from 6,542 to 28,751, and its paid search visits 220.7%. The others use these channels lightly: MedImpact, with 2.1 times Rightway’s visits, drew 23,382 from paid search and 32,143 from email.
Source: SEMrush Traffic Analytics, Traffic Journey and monthly Email and Paid Search channels. Modelled estimates.
A MedImpact visit lasts 14:48, 2.9 times a Judi Health visit. Navitus visits halved in length.
MedImpact visits average 14:48 and 7.3 pages with a bounce rate of 31.2%, the profile of members and pharmacies working inside portals. Rightway moved towards that profile: pages per visit rose from 3.7 to 5.7 and visit length grew 32.3%. SmithRx (05:14, bounce 65.6%) and Judi Health (05:08, bounce 67.0%) look like marketing sites.
Navitus changed most. A year ago it held the longest visits in the set at 16:55; its average visit is now 08:10 (-51.7%) and pages per visit fell from 6.8 to 4.2, while unique visitors rose 47.0%. More, shorter visits suggest a broader audience arriving, not existing users leaving.
Average visit duration, Oct 2025 to Sep 2026, with change year on year
14:48
09:54
08:10
05:14
05:08
The most search-dependent PBM is the only one whose organic visits fell. It turned to paid search instead.
SmithRx’s organic search visits went from 71,035 in October to December 2025 to 65,849 in July to September 2026 (-7.3%). Organic search rose at the other four: +151.1% at Rightway, +78.8% at Judi Health, +27.2% at MedImpact and +17.8% at Navitus. Over the same quarters SmithRx’s paid search visits rose 650.2%, from 1,314 to 9,857.
AI assistants referred 22,947 visits across the set in the year. Per 10,000 visits, Judi Health draws the most (64.0) and MedImpact the fewest (20.5); SmithRx sits at 39.0. ChatGPT is the largest named assistant for all five.
Correlation, not causation. This page reports AI referrals and organic search movements side by side and makes no claim that one caused the other, including SmithRx’s organic decline. This data cannot show cause. AI Overview keyword coverage is not part of this edition.
Source: SEMrush Traffic Analytics, monthly Organic Search and Paid Search channels, Traffic Journey AI traffic. Modelled estimates.
Six gaps. Two are open here.
Outside Rightway, paid search is barely contested. The other four drew 57,042 paid search visits between them.
SEMrush recorded 159,189 paid search visits across the set, 64.2% to Rightway. MedImpact drew 23,382, SmithRx 16,980, Navitus 9,154 and Judi Health 7,526. Judi Health is the only PBM whose paid search fell between the first and last quarters (-44.5%).
Employers and benefits consultants searching for an alternative to the large PBMs meet little paid competition beyond Rightway. Low figures in modelled data can mean activity below the detection threshold, so read this as an absence of meaningful investment, not proof of none.
Named AI assistants sent SmithRx 318 visits in a year, and Rightway 564.
ChatGPT sent Rightway 561 of its 564 named AI referrals and SmithRx 305 of 318. Gemini referred visits to only two PBMs, Navitus (291) and SmithRx (13), and Claude to Navitus alone (70). MedImpact drew 1,135, Navitus 868 and Judi Health 791.
The volumes are small for everyone, which is the opportunity. The answers assistants give when an employer asks which transparent PBM to consider are still being formed, and the fastest-growing PBM in the set barely features in them.
What drove Rightway’s July and August surge, and whether it reached buyers or members
In full report
Why Navitus visits halved in length while its audience grew
In full report
What MedImpact’s February 2026 spike was, and why it did not hold
In full report
Which searches SmithRx began paying for as its organic visits slipped
In full report
Get the full transparent PBM report
- All six gaps, with the figures behind each and the move we would make
- Twelve months of monthly traffic by channel for every PBM
- A month by month read of Rightway’s rise and the spikes at MedImpact and Navitus
- AI referral sources for each PBM, assistant by assistant
Tell us your vertical and we will send the full transparent PBM report.
We send the report by email and follow up once to offer a walkthrough.
Method and provenance
- Source
- SEMrush Traffic Analytics: Overview, Traffic Journey, monthly Visits, monthly channel trends (direct, organic search, referral, paid search, organic social, paid social, email, display, ChatGPT) and AI traffic by source exports for medimpact.com, rightwayhealthcare.com, navitus.com, smithrx.com and judi.health.
- Market
- Worldwide, all devices. Figures are not limited to any one country.
- Modelled data
- Visit, engagement and channel figures are SEMrush modelled estimates, not first-party analytics from any of these PBMs. They are suitable for comparing competitors with each other and over time, not for stating any PBM’s exact traffic. Visits include every subdomain, so members, pharmacies and clients signed in to portals hosted on these domains count alongside visitors to marketing pages.
- Judi Health
- Judi Health is the brand Capital Rx now trades under. The judi.health domain drew 6,689 visits in the prior twelve months and 18,624 in October 2025 alone, so its year-on-year change is shown but excluded from the like-for-like category growth. Traffic to the older capitalrx.com domain is not in this pack.
- AI exposure
- AI referral visits and organic search movements are reported as correlation only. Nothing on this page claims that AI assistants or AI Overviews caused a change in organic or any other traffic. AI Overview keyword coverage is not part of this edition. AI referral totals use the Traffic Journey AI traffic channel. The by-source export names 8 sources for 3,676 of those visits (16.0%), 66.9% of them from ChatGPT; SEMrush does not name a source for the rest.
- Period
- Oct 2025 to Sep 2026, compared with Oct 2024 to Sep 2025. Momentum compares the first quarter of the period (Oct to Dec 2025) with the last (Jul to Sep 2026), is not seasonally adjusted, and avoids single-month spikes at MedImpact (February 2026) and Navitus (January 2026) that sit between the two.
- Rounding
- Visits are shown as whole numbers, except the category total, shown in millions to two decimal places. Percentages and growth rates are computed from the raw counts and shown to one decimal place (AI share of visits to two), so shares may not sum to exactly 100%. Channel shares are of each PBM’s Traffic Journey total, which differs from Overview visits by at most 0.08%.
- Not in this edition
- Authority Score, organic keyword positions, branded and non-branded search, backlinks, referring domains, paid search creative, AI Overview coverage and top pages by share of traffic.